Page 1 of 3 (44 results found)

20 units reserved in Shelter Island, New York yesterday. Reserve now to secure your unit.

Customer Favorite
9 more photosOpen Now!

CubeSmart Self Storage - Southold

1040 Horton LaneSouthold NY 119714.7 miles away
3 out of 5 - Based on 1 review

Starting at $96.30

5' x 5' Locker

4' Ceiling, Interior

10% Off

5' x 10' Unit

1st Floor, Interior

10% Off

10' x 10' Unit

Drive Up Access

10% Off and Half Off First Month

Compare 10 units at this facility »
5 more photosOpen Now!

GoodFriend Self-Storage - East Hampton

17 Goodfriend DriveEast Hampton NY 119378.6 miles away

Starting at $189.00

5' x 5' Unit

6th Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

5' x 10' Unit

6th Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

5' x 15' Unit

1st Floor, Alarm, Outdoor Access

Compare 6 units at this facility »
18 more photosOpen Now!

Prime Storage - Bridgehampton

229 Butter LaneBridgehampton NY 119328.9 miles away

Starting at $153.00

5' x 5' Unit

2nd Floor, Interior

First Month 25% Off

5' x 10' Unit

2nd Floor, Interior

First Month $1

10' x 10' Unit

2nd Floor, Interior

First Month $1

Compare 17 units at this facility »
8 more photosOpen Now!

Life Storage - East Hampton

9 Hardscrabble CtEast Hampton NY 119379.9 miles away
4 out of 5 - Based on 1 review

Starting at $119.00

5' x 5' Unit

24 Hour Access, 2nd Floor, Interior, Swing Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month 50% off!

5' x 10' Unit

24 Hour Access, 2nd Floor, Interior, Swing Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month 50% off!

10' x 10' Unit

24 Hour Access, 2nd Floor, Interior, Swing Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month Free!

Compare 31 units at this facility »
8 more photosOpen Now!

Life Storage - Southampton - 59 Mariner Drive

59 Mariner DrSouthampton NY 1196811.9 miles away

Starting at $189.00

No 5' x 5' Units Available

5' x 10' Unit

-1st Floor, 24 Hour Access, Climate Controlled, Humidity Controlled, Interior, Swing Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month Free!

10' x 10' Unit

-1st Floor, 24 Hour Access, Climate Controlled, Humidity Controlled, Interior, Swing Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month 50% off!

Compare 8 units at this facility »
8 more photosOpen Now!

Life Storage - Southampton - 99 Mariner Drive

99 Mariner DrSouthampton NY 1196812 miles away

Starting at $92.00

5' x 5' Unit

24 Hour Access, 2nd Floor, Interior, Swing Door

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 10' Unit

24 Hour Access, 2nd Floor, Interior, Swing Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month 50% off!

Compare 13 units at this facility »
Additional facilities near Shelter Island, NY
9 more photos

CubeSmart Self Storage - Old Saybrook - 45 School House Rd

45 School House RdOld Saybrook CT 0647515.7 miles away
5 out of 5 - Based on 3 reviews

Starting at $88.40

5' x 5' Unit

1st Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

10% Off and First Month Free

5' x 10' Unit

1st Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

15% Off and First Month Free

10' x 10' Unit

1st Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

15% Off and First Month Free

Compare 8 units at this facility »
9 more photosOpen Now!

CubeSmart Self Storage - Old Saybrook - 167-3 Elm Street

167-3 Elm StreetOld Saybrook CT 0647516.1 miles away
4.5 out of 5 - Based on 4 reviews

Starting at $67.15

5' x 5' Unit

1st Floor, Interior

15% Off and First Month Free

5' x 10' Unit

Drive Up Access

15% Off and First Month Free

10' x 10' Unit

Drive Up Access

10% Off

Compare 12 units at this facility »
8 more photosOpen Now!

Global Self Storage - Heritage Park (Formerly Tuxis Self Storage)

6 Heritage Park RoadClinton CT 0641316.8 miles away
5 out of 5 - Based on 1 review

Starting at $79.00

5' x 5' Unit

1st Floor, 24 Hour Access, Interior

1st Month Rent FREE with Autopay- major credit card & min. 3-month stay REQUIRED

5' x 10' Unit

24 Hour Access, Drive Up Access

1st Month Rent FREE with Autopay- major credit card & min. 3-month stay REQUIRED

10' x 10' Unit

24 Hour Access, Drive Up Access

1st Month Rent FREE with Autopay- major credit card & min. 3-month stay REQUIRED

Compare 5 units at this facility »
8 more photosOpen Now!

Life Storage - Hampton Bays

173 W Montauk HwyHampton Bays NY 1194616.9 miles away
5 out of 5 - Based on 4 reviews

Starting at $135.00

5' x 5' Unit

24 Hour Access, 2nd Floor, Interior, Swing Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month 50% off!

5' x 10' Unit

24 Hour Access, 2nd Floor, Interior, Swing Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month Free!

10' x 10' Unit

24 Hour Access, 2nd Floor, Interior, Roll Up Door

Compare 21 units at this facility »
Open Now!

Life Storage - Riverhead - 345 Flanders Road

345 Flanders RoadRiverhead NY 1190119.5 miles away

Starting at $69.00

5' x 5' Unit

2nd Floor, Interior, Swing Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month 50% off!

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 10' Unit

Drive Up Access, Roll Up Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month 50% off!

Compare 15 units at this facility »
9 more photosOpen Now!

CubeSmart Self Storage - Riverhead

99 Mill RoadRiverhead NY 1190121 miles away
4 out of 5 - Based on 1 review

Starting at $113.05

5' x 5' Locker

4' Ceiling, Interior

10% Off and Half Off First Month

5' x 10' Unit

1st Floor, Interior

15% Off and Half Off First Month

10' x 10' Unit

Drive Up Access

10% Off and First Month Free

Compare 9 units at this facility »
6 more photosOpen Now!

East Lyme Rent-A-Space

9 King Arthur DrNiantic CT 0635721.3 miles away
5 out of 5 - Based on 2 reviews

Starting at $55.00

5' x 5' Unit

24 Hour Access, 9' Ceiling, Drive Up Access, Roll Up Door

No 5' x 10' Units Available

No 10' x 10' Units Available

Compare 2 units at this facility »
8 more photosOpen Now!

Prime Storage - Westhampton Beach

98 Depot RoadWesthampton Beach NY 1197823.2 miles away

Starting at $109.00

5' x 5' Unit

Climate Controlled, Interior, Underground Level

First Month $1

5' x 10' Unit

1st Floor, Interior

10' x 10' Unit

Outdoor Access

First Month 50% Off

Compare 17 units at this facility »
4 more photosOpen Now!

Cross Road Rent-A-Space

175 Cross RdWaterford CT 0638523.4 miles away
4.5 out of 5 - Based on 3 reviews

Starting at $80.00

5' x 5' Unit

Drive Up Access, Roll Up Door

5' x 10' Unit

Drive Up Access, Roll Up Door

10' x 10' Unit

Climate Controlled, Interior, Roll Up Door

Compare 8 units at this facility »
8 more photosOpen Now!

Safe N Sound Self Storage - Groton

451 Bridge StGroton CT 0634024.6 miles away

Starting at $80.00

5' x 5' Unit

24 Hour Access, Climate Controlled, Drive Up Access, Humidity Controlled, Swing Door

5' x 10' Unit

1st Floor, 24 Hour Access, Climate Controlled, Interior, Roll Up Door

10' x 10' Unit

24 Hour Access, Climate Controlled, Drive Up Access, Humidity Controlled, Roll Up Door

The first full month free with six month lease agreement

Compare 11 units at this facility »
10 more photosOpen Now!

CubeSmart Self Storage - Gales Ferry

1501 Route 12Gales Ferry CT 0633527.2 miles away
4.5 out of 5 - Based on 12 reviews

Starting at $51.30

5' x 5' Unit

1st Floor, Interior

15% Off and First Month Free

5' x 10' Unit

1st Floor, Interior

10% Off and Half Off First Month

5' x 15' Unit

1st Floor, Interior

15% Off and First Month Free

Compare 7 units at this facility »
10 more photosOpen Now!

CubeSmart Self Storage - Mystic

868 Flanders RoadMystic CT 0635527.3 miles away
4.5 out of 5 - Based on 5 reviews

Starting at $52.20

5' x 5' Unit

1st Floor, Interior

15% Off and First Month Free

5' x 10' Unit

1st Floor, Interior

10% Off and First Month Free

10' x 10' Unit

Drive Up Access

15% Off and First Month Free

Compare 10 units at this facility »
3 more photosOpen Now!

A Sure Thing Storage

19 South Main StreetBranford CT 0640528.7 miles away
5 out of 5 - Based on 1 review

Starting at $75.00

5' x 5' Unit

1st Floor, 24 Hour Access, Climate Controlled, Interior, Roll Up Door

5' x 10' Unit

24 Hour Access, Drive Up Access, Roll Up Door

10' x 10' Unit

24 Hour Access, Drive Up Access, Roll Up Door

Compare 5 units at this facility »
8 more photosOpen Now!

The Lock Up Storage Centers - Branford

247 North Main StreetBranford CT 0640528.7 miles away
4.5 out of 5 - Based on 2 reviews

Starting at $125.00

5' x 5' Unit

24 Hour Access, Climate Controlled, Interior

See Manager for Move In Specials!

5' x 10' Unit

24 Hour Access, Climate Controlled, Interior

See Manager for Move In Specials!

10' x 10' Unit

24 Hour Access, Climate Controlled, Interior

See Manager for Move In Specials!

Compare 17 units at this facility »
Best Priced Storage Units in Shelter Island, NY

How does self-storage in Shelter Island work?

A storage unit’s price is based on several factors, including the facility’s amenities (such as 24/7 access, free use of truck), the storage unit’s amenities (such as climate control, electrical outlet), facility location, unit location (a ground floor unit will be more expensive), and overall demand in your area.

When looking at pricing for storage units in Shelter Island, it’s important to think about rental rates in terms of price for value. Sometimes, the cheapest storage unit doesn’t always mean it’s the best unit for YOUR needs.