Page 1 of 3 (56 results found)

10 units reserved in Fire Island, New York yesterday. Reserve now to secure your unit.

Customer Favorite
5 more photos

The Moving and Storage Center of Long Island

260 Moffitt BoulevardIslip NY 117517 miles away

Starting at $139.00

5' x 5' Unit

1st Floor, Air Cooled, Heated, Humidity Controlled, Interior, Swing Door

Waived admin fee when you reserve online

5' x 10' Unit

1st Floor, Air Cooled, Heated, Humidity Controlled, Interior, Roll Up Door

Waived admin fee when you reserve online

10' x 10' Unit

1st Floor, Air Cooled, Heated, Humidity Controlled, Interior, Roll Up Door

Waived admin fee when you reserve online

Compare 6 units at this facility »
7 more photos

Life Storage - Bay Shore

110 Saxon AveBay Shore NY 117067.5 miles away

Starting at $139.00

5' x 5' Unit

1st Floor, 9' Ceiling, Climate Controlled, Interior, Roll Up Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month Free!

5' x 10' Unit

1st Floor, 9' Ceiling, Climate Controlled, Interior, Roll Up Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month Free!

5' x 15' Unit

1st Floor, 9' Ceiling, Climate Controlled, Interior, Roll Up Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month Free!

Compare 22 units at this facility »
14 more photos

The Self Storage Vault

59 Orinoco DriveBrightwaters NY 117187.9 miles away
5 out of 5 - Based on 1 review

Starting at $149.00

5' x 5' Locker

1st Floor, 4' Ceiling, Climate Controlled, Interior, Swing Door

Only $19 per month for the first three full months

5' x 10' Unit

2nd Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior, Swing Door

50% off for the first two full months and free lock when you reserve online

No 10' x 10' Units Available

Compare 4 units at this facility »
9 more photos

CubeSmart Self Storage - Holbrook - 640 Broadway Avenue

640 Broadway AvenueHolbrook NY 117419.5 miles away
5 out of 5 - Based on 2 reviews

Starting at $135.90

5' x 5' Unit

Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

10% Off and First Month Free

5' x 10' Unit

Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

10% Off and First Month Free

10' x 10' Unit

Drive Up Access

15% Off and First Month Free

Compare 12 units at this facility »
8 more photos

iStorage Bayport

709 Church StreetBayport NY 117059.6 miles away

Starting at $102.00

5' x 5' Unit

Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

First Month Free -1

5' x 10' Unit

Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

Refer A Friend

No 10' x 10' Units Available

Compare 3 units at this facility »
8 more photos

CubeSmart Self Storage - Patchogue - 120 River Avenue

120 River AvenuePatchogue NY 1177210.1 miles away

Starting at $152.10

No 5' x 5' Units Available

5' x 10' Unit

Drive Up Access

10% Off and Half Off First Month

10' x 10' Unit

Drive Up Access

10% Off and Half Off First Month

Compare 5 units at this facility »
8 more photos

CubeSmart Self Storage - Bay Shore

1775 5th AvenueBay Shore NY 1170610.3 miles away
5 out of 5 - Based on 2 reviews

Starting at $90.10

5' x 5' Unit

Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

15% Off and First Month Free

5' x 10' Unit

Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

15% Off and First Month Free

10' x 10' Unit

Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

15% Off and First Month Free

Compare 19 units at this facility »
8 more photos

Storage Post Islandia

1960 Veterans Memorial HwyIslandia NY 1174910.6 miles away
4.5 out of 5 - Based on 16 reviews

Starting at $82.00

No 5' x 5' Units Available

6' x 8' Unit

Drive Up Access

First Month Free

10' x 10' Unit

Drive Up Access

First Month Free

Compare 11 units at this facility »
14 more photos

CubeSmart Self Storage - Patchogue - 257 Waverly Avenue

257 Waverly AvenuePatchogue NY 1177210.7 miles away
4.5 out of 5 - Based on 3 reviews

Starting at $121.50

5' x 5' Unit

Interior, Upstairs (Access via Lift)

10% Off and First Month Free

5' x 10' Unit

Interior, Upstairs (Access via Lift)

10% Off and First Month Free

10' x 10' Unit

Interior, Upstairs (Access via Lift)

15% Off and First Month Free

Compare 19 units at this facility »
9 more photos

CubeSmart Self Storage - North Babylon

240 Bay Shore RoadNorth Babylon NY 1170311.1 miles away
4.5 out of 5 - Based on 5 reviews

Starting at $124.20

No 5' x 5' Units Available

5' x 10' Unit

Interior, Upstairs (Access via Lift)

10% Off and First Month Free

9' x 10' Unit

Interior, Upstairs (Access via Stairs)

15% Off and First Month Free

Compare 8 units at this facility »
10 more photos

America Safe N Sound Self Storage

1800 Prime PlHauppauge NY 1178811.5 miles away
5 out of 5 - Based on 9 reviews

Starting at $115.00

5' x 5' Unit

Climate Controlled, Drive Up Access, Humidity Controlled, Roll Up Door

5' x 10' Unit

Drive Up Access, Roll Up Door

10' x 10' Unit

Drive Up Access, Roll Up Door

Compare 8 units at this facility »
10 more photos

StorQuest - West Babylon/Farmingdale

260 Farmingdale RoadWest Babylon NY 1170411.8 miles away
5 out of 5 - Based on 1 review

Starting at $100.00

5' x 5' Unit

Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

$1 First Month Rent

5' x 10' Unit

Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

$1 First Month Rent

10' x 10' Unit

Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

$1 First Month Rent

Compare 37 units at this facility »
8 more photos

Life Storage - Deer Park - Grand Boulevard

715 Grand BoulevardDeer Park NY 1172911.8 miles away
4.5 out of 5 - Based on 2 reviews

Starting at $135.00

5' x 5' Unit

-1st Floor, 10' Ceiling, Climate Controlled, Interior, Swing Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month 50% off!

5' x 10' Unit

10' Ceiling, 2nd Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior, Swing Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month Free!

10' x 10' Unit

-1st Floor, 10' Ceiling, Climate Controlled, Interior, Roll Up Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month Free!

Compare 35 units at this facility »
9 more photos

Life Storage - Lindenhurst

101 E Hoffman AveLindenhurst NY 1175711.9 miles away

Starting at $168.00

5' x 5' Unit

2nd Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior, Swing Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month Free!

5' x 10' Unit

1st Floor, 9' Ceiling, Climate Controlled, Interior, Swing Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month 50% off!

10' x 10' Unit

2nd Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior, Roll Up Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month 50% off!

Compare 30 units at this facility »
11 more photos

Prime Storage - Holtsville (Waverly)

970 Waverly AvenueHoltsville NY 1174212.5 miles away
5 out of 5 - Based on 1 review

Starting at $94.00

5' x 5' Unit

Alarm, Outdoor Access

5' x 10' Unit

1st Floor, Alarm, Interior

First Month $1

10' x 10' Unit

1st Floor, Alarm, Interior

First Month 50% Off

Compare 11 units at this facility »
4 more photos

4 Storage - Deer Park

541 Acorn StreetDeer Park NY 1172912.9 miles away

Starting at $124.00

5' x 5' Unit

Drive Up Access

5' x 10' Unit

2nd Floor, Interior

10' x 10' Unit

2nd Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

Compare 22 units at this facility »
9 more photos

Omega Self Storage of Amityville

185 Sunrise HwyAmityville NY 1170114.4 miles away
3.5 out of 5 - Based on 10 reviews

Starting at $99.00

No 5' x 5' Units Available

5' x 10' Unit

2nd Floor, Interior, Roll Up Door

The second full month free

No 10' x 10' Units Available

Compare 2 units at this facility »
8 more photos

Life Storage - Amityville

24 Sterling PlaceAmityville NY 1170114.4 miles away

Starting at $127.00

5' x 5' Unit

10' Ceiling, 2nd Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior, Roll Up Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month Free!

5' x 10' Unit

10' Ceiling, 2nd Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior, Roll Up Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month Free!

10' x 10' Unit

10' Ceiling, 3rd Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior, Roll Up Door

Pay the remaining days this month, next month Free!

Compare 57 units at this facility »
2 more photos

Smithtown Mini Storage

650 Middle Country RoadSt. James NY 1178014.7 miles away
4 out of 5 - Based on 19 reviews

Starting at $70.00

No 5' x 5' Units Available

5' x 10' Unit

2nd Floor, Interior, Light in Unit, Roll Up Door

$70 off for the second full month with one month lease agreement

10' x 10' Unit

2nd Floor, Light in Unit, Outdoor Access, Roll Up Door

$135 off for the second full month with one month lease agreement

Compare 4 units at this facility »
8 more photos

A Space Place

3220 Horseblock RdMedford NY 1176314.9 miles away
4 out of 5 - Based on 7 reviews

Starting at $104.00

5' x 5' Unit

2nd Floor, Interior

5' x 10' Unit

2nd Floor, Interior

First Month $1

10' x 10' Unit

2nd Floor, Interior

First Month 50% Off

Compare 10 units at this facility »
Best Priced Storage Units in Fire Island, NY

How does self-storage in Fire Island work?

A storage unit’s price is based on several factors, including the facility’s amenities (such as 24/7 access, free use of truck), the storage unit’s amenities (such as climate control, electrical outlet), facility location, unit location (a ground floor unit will be more expensive), and overall demand in your area.

When looking at pricing for storage units in Fire Island, it’s important to think about rental rates in terms of price for value. Sometimes, the cheapest storage unit doesn’t always mean it’s the best unit for YOUR needs.