Extra Space Storage - 4281 - Bay Shore - Howells Rd

Samantha Pollucci

Had an excellent experience renting a unit at this location. Manny helped me every step of the way he even called me and let me know that I had accidentally left my unit unlocked. I finally have enough storage that I know longer need the storage unit anymore but would definitely recommend!

Zachary Milligan

February 6, 2026

Multiple units broken into on the night of 2/4/26. Our units lock was cut, our stuff ransacked and approximately $6k worth of stuff was stolen less than two weeks after moving in. Extra Space will direct you to file an insurance claim and absolve themselves of all responsibility. Recommend you get your own insurance that covers full replacement cost, their provided insurance only covers assessed value which means they’ll only give you the depreciated value of your belongings. Included pictures of our unit before and after the break in.

Greg Oechslin

Just recently got a unit. Couldn't be happier(as Ive dealt with other Storage facilities and havent had the best experience personally). The guy who set up everything, I think it was Manny, was super helpful. Definitely will recommend!!!

Delmer Mondragon

Today I visited Extra Space Storage and Manny helped me change the size of my storage unit. As always, he was very friendly, professional, and attentive throughout the entire process. Honestly, if you want to speak with someone honest and genuinely helpful, Manny is the right person. He has helped me a lot every time I’ve needed assistance, and he always provides outstanding customer service. Very thankful for all his help and attention.

Mohamed Saleh

Manny was extremely helpful with all the information required and answered all my questions with ease. Made the process very smooth and I felt secure with my belongings here. Very polite and professional. Would highly recommend these guys to anyone.