1 - 29 of 29 Cheap Small Storage Facilities in Middle Island, NY

Sort By:

0.2 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 6078 - Middle Island - Middle Country Rd

901 Middle Country Road, Middle Island, NY, 11953

5' x 10'

$81.00

$73.00

View All Units

Photo of Extra Space Storage - 4139 - Farmingville - Horseblock Rd

5.3 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 4139 - Farmingville - Horseblock Rd

1027 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, NY, 11738

5' x 10'

$121.00

$110.00

View All Units

Photo of Extra Space Storage - 0470 - Ridge - Francis Mooney Rd

3.5 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 0470 - Ridge - Francis Mooney Rd

14 Francis Mooney Drive, Ridge, NY, 11961

5' x 10'

$76.00

$69.00

View All Units

Photo of Public Storage - Coram - 544 Middle Country Road

3.8 miles away

5.0(18)

Public Storage - Coram - 544 Middle Country Road

550 Middle Country Road, Coram, NY, 11727

5' x 10'

3 left

$67.00

$54.00

View All Units

4.6 miles away

4.5(3)

Prime Storage - Medford

3220 Horseblock Rd, Medford, NY, 11763

5' x 10'

2 left

$119.00

$101.00

View All Units

Photo of Public Storage - Mount Sinai - 508 Route 25A

5.4 miles away

5.0(1030)

Public Storage - Mount Sinai - 508 Route 25A

508 Route 25A, Mount Sinai, NY, 11766

5' x 10'

1 left

$109.00

$82.00

View All Units

Photo of Prime Storage - Port Jefferson Station

5.5 miles away

3.0(2)

Prime Storage - Port Jefferson Station

1184 New York 112, Port Jefferson Station, NY, 11776

5' x 10'

$134.00

$119.00

View All Units

8.7 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 1398 - Centereach - Middle Country Rd

2626 Middle Country Road, Centereach, NY, 11720

5' x 10'

$99.00

$89.00

View All Units

3.5 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 0270 - Coram - Route 112

2025 New York 112, Coram, NY, 11727

5' x 10'

$83.00

$74.00

View All Units

6.9 miles away

5.0(10)

Prime Storage - Centereach

21 Hammond Road, Centereach, NY, 11720

5' x 10'

$126.00

$94.00

View All Units

6.7 miles away

Prime Storage - Centereach S Coleman Rd

20 South Coleman Road, Centereach, NY, 11720

5' x 10'

1 left

$250.00

$43.00

View All Units

Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage - Riverhead

13.4 miles away

3.0(2)

CubeSmart Self Storage - Riverhead

99 Mill Road, Riverhead, NY, 11901

5' x 10'

$225.00

$135.00

View All Units

4.1 miles away

Devon Self Storage Yaphank, New York

84 Long Island Avenue, Yaphank, NY, 11980

5' x 10'

1 left

$89.00

View All Units

Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage - Holbrook - 640 Broadway Avenue

10.1 miles away

5.0(4)

CubeSmart Self Storage - Holbrook - 640 Broadway Avenue

640 Broadway Avenue, Holbrook, NY, 11741

5' x 10'

$114.00

$85.50

View All Units

Photo of Extra Space Storage - 7204 - Islandia - Veterans Memorial Hwy

13.5 miles away

4.0(2)

Extra Space Storage - 7204 - Islandia - Veterans Memorial Hwy

1960 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia, NY, 11749

6' x 8'

$66.00

$60.00

View All Units

Photo of The Lock Up Self Storage - East Setauket

8 miles away

4.5(8)

The Lock Up Self Storage - East Setauket

380 Mark Tree Road, Setauket East Setauket, NY, 11733

5' x 10'

1 left

$167.00

$122.00

View All Units

Photo of Extra Space Storage - 7665 - Holtsville - Waverly Ave

7.3 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 7665 - Holtsville - Waverly Ave

970 Waverly Avenue, Holtsville, NY, 11742

5' x 10'

$107.00

$96.00

View All Units

Photo of Public Storage - Nesconset - 770 Nesconset Hwy

11.5 miles away

4.5(12)

Public Storage - Nesconset - 770 Nesconset Hwy

770 Nesconset Hwy, Nesconset, NY, 11767

5' x 10'

1 left

$124.00

$93.00

View All Units

Photo of Extra Space Storage - 1391 - Bohemia - Johnson Ave

10.9 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 1391 - Bohemia - Johnson Ave

510 Johnson Avenue, Bohemia, NY, 11716

5' x 10'

$98.00

$89.00

View All Units

9.4 miles away

4.5(3)

Prime Storage - Shirley

235 William Floyd Parkway, Shirley, NY, 11967

5' x 10'

1 left

$192.00

View All Units

14.2 miles away

Prime Storage - Riverhead

209 Marcy Avenue, Riverhead, NY, 11901

5' x 10'

3 left

$145.00

$136.00

View All Units

Photo of Public Storage - Patchogue - 601 W Sunrise Highway

9 miles away

5.0(25)

Public Storage - Patchogue - 601 W Sunrise Highway

601 W Sunrise Highway, Patchogue, NY, 11772

5' x 10'

1 left

$93.00

$70.00

View All Units

Photo of Prime Storage - Bohemia - Lincoln Avenue

10.8 miles away

4.5(10)

Prime Storage - Bohemia - Lincoln Avenue

868 Lincoln Avenue, Bohemia, NY, 11716

5' x 10'

1 left

$131.00

$47.00

View All Units

7.8 miles away

4.5(7)

Storage Post - Setauket (East)

171 North Belle Mead Avenue, Setauket- East Setauket, NY, 11733

5' x 10'

1 left

$146.00

View All Units

14.9 miles away

5.0(3)

Prime Storage - Central Islip

625 Eastview Drive, Central Islip, NY, 11722

5' x 10'

$150.00

$88.00

View All Units

11.6 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage NY Saint James Middle Country Rd

514 Middle Country Road, Saint James, NY, 11780

5' x 10'

$197.00

$98.50

View All Units

6.6 miles away

4.5(1)

StorQuest - Shirley / Smith

393 Smith Road, Shirley, NY, 11967

5' x 10'

$79.00

View All Units

Photo of Extra Space Storage - 0805 - Islandia - Express Drive South

13.8 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 0805 - Islandia - Express Drive South

3016 Express Drive South, Islandia, NY, 11749

5' x 10'

$69.00

$62.00

View All Units

11.4 miles away

Storage Post - Bohemia

1295 Lakeland Avenue, Bohemia, NY, 11716

5' x 10'

$29.00

View All Units

Middle Island, NY Small Self Storage Information

Average Unit Price

Based on 8 storage units reserved in Middle Island over the past 5 months.

$161.00

Up $96.00

Compared to last month

Browse Self Storage in Nearby New York Cities

Browse Middle Island Self Storage by Amenity

Browse Middle Island Self Storage by Vehicle

Customer reviews of SelfStorage.com

Eric Williams

February 9, 2026

Eric owner

Na good nothings to note

Bonnie Browning

February 17, 2026

The cost and how easy it was to rent.

Sarah Pugh

April 30, 2026

The manager of the facility was very…

The manager of the facility was very helpful and friendly.

See more reviews on TrustPilot

Home
New York
Middle Island

Cheap Small Self Storage Units in Middle Island, NY

Filters

1 - 29 of 29 Cheap Small Storage Facilities in Middle Island, NY

Extra Space Storage - 6078 - Middle Island - Middle Country Rd

Extra Space Storage - 4139 - Farmingville - Horseblock Rd

Extra Space Storage - 0470 - Ridge - Francis Mooney Rd

Public Storage - Coram - 544 Middle Country Road

Prime Storage - Medford

Public Storage - Mount Sinai - 508 Route 25A

Prime Storage - Port Jefferson Station

Extra Space Storage - 1398 - Centereach - Middle Country Rd

Extra Space Storage - 0270 - Coram - Route 112

Prime Storage - Centereach

Prime Storage - Centereach S Coleman Rd

CubeSmart Self Storage - Riverhead

Devon Self Storage Yaphank, New York

CubeSmart Self Storage - Holbrook - 640 Broadway Avenue

Extra Space Storage - 7204 - Islandia - Veterans Memorial Hwy

The Lock Up Self Storage - East Setauket

Extra Space Storage - 7665 - Holtsville - Waverly Ave

Public Storage - Nesconset - 770 Nesconset Hwy

Extra Space Storage - 1391 - Bohemia - Johnson Ave

Prime Storage - Shirley

Prime Storage - Riverhead

Public Storage - Patchogue - 601 W Sunrise Highway

Prime Storage - Bohemia - Lincoln Avenue

Storage Post - Setauket (East)

Prime Storage - Central Islip

CubeSmart Self Storage NY Saint James Middle Country Rd

StorQuest - Shirley / Smith

Extra Space Storage - 0805 - Islandia - Express Drive South

Storage Post - Bohemia

Middle Island, NY Small Self Storage Information

Self Storage Prices in Middle Island, NY

Average Unit Price

Browse Self Storage in Nearby New York Cities

Browse Middle Island Self Storage by Amenity

Browse Middle Island Self Storage by Vehicle

Customer reviews of SelfStorage.com