Cheap Medium Self Storage Units in New Castle, IN

Filters

1 - 29 of 29 Cheap Medium Storage Facilities in New Castle, IN

Sort By:
Photo of KO Storage of New Castle - S 103

2 miles away

3.0(2)

KO Storage of New Castle - S 103

2359 Indiana 103, New Castle, IN, 47362

10' x 10'

$89.00

View All Units
Photo of Miles of Storage - New Castle

0.8 miles away

Miles of Storage - New Castle

531 North Memorial Drive, New Castle, IN, 47362

10' x 10'

$75.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 2180 - Centerville - Airport Rd

22.8 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 2180 - Centerville - Airport Rd

1183 Airport Road, Centerville, IN, 47330

10' x 10'

$62.00

$56.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 2146 - Anderson - Madison Ave

19 miles away

3.5(1)

Extra Space Storage - 2146 - Anderson - Madison Ave

6529 Madison Avenue, Anderson, IN, 46013

10' x 10'

$69.00

$62.00

View All Units
Photo of Go Store It - Anderson - 1823 East 53rd Street

17.7 miles away

5.0(3)

Go Store It - Anderson - 1823 East 53rd Street

1823 East 53rd Street, Anderson, IN, 46013

10' x 10'

Deal
2 left
$143.00

$87.00

View All Units
Photo of Storage Rentals of America - Anderson - Scott St

22.1 miles away

4.5(1)

Storage Rentals of America - Anderson - Scott St

121 Scott St, Anderson, IN, 46012

10' x 10'

Deal

$62.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 2182 - Richmond - National Rd

22.8 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 2182 - Richmond - National Rd

4611 West National Road, Richmond, IN, 47374

10' x 10'

Deal
$41.00

$37.00

View All Units
Photo of Public Storage - Fishers - 13720 E 118th St

29.2 miles away

5.0(9)

Public Storage - Fishers - 13720 E 118th St

13720 E 118th St, Fishers, IN, 46037

10' x 10'

Deal
1 left
$96.00

$88.00

View All Units
Photo of SOA - L025 Broadway 2 (Anderson, Indiana)

22.1 miles away

SOA - L025 Broadway 2 (Anderson, Indiana)

2940 Broadway Street, Anderson, IN, 46012

10' x 10'

1 left

$130.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 2181 - Richmond - Hawkins Rd

27 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 2181 - Richmond - Hawkins Rd

1975 Hawkins Road, Richmond, IN, 47374

10' x 10'

$83.00

$74.00

View All Units
Photo of Miles of Storage - Anderson (M.L.K. Jr Blvd)

20.5 miles away

Miles of Storage - Anderson (M.L.K. Jr Blvd)

5327 Doctor Martin Luther King Junior Boulevard, Anderson, IN, 46013

10' x 10'

$75.00

View All Units
Photo of Storage Rentals of America - Muncie - Wheeling Ave.

21.6 miles away

3.5(3)

Storage Rentals of America - Muncie - Wheeling Ave.

5500 N Wheeling Avenue, Muncie, IN, 47304

10' x 10'

Deal
1 left

$42.00

View All Units
Photo of Amazon Storage - Pendleton

25.3 miles away

Amazon Storage - Pendleton

8299 Indiana 13, Pendleton, IN, 46064

10' x 10'

$96.00

View All Units
Photo of Storage Rentals of America - Yorktown - Kilgore Ave.

18.1 miles away

2.5(3)

Storage Rentals of America - Yorktown - Kilgore Ave.

6691 West Kilgore Avenue, Yorktown, IN, 47396

10' x 10'

Deal

$31.00

View All Units
Photo of Miles of Storage - Anderson (Main Street)

20.2 miles away

Miles of Storage - Anderson (Main Street)

1434 Main Street, Anderson, IN, 46016

8' x 11'

1 left

$63.00

View All Units
Photo of Storage Rentals of America - Muncie - Jackson St.

18.4 miles away

5.0(1)

Storage Rentals of America - Muncie - Jackson St.

4701 East Jackson Street, Muncie, IN, 47303

10' x 10'

Deal
1 left

$41.00

View All Units
Photo of Miles of Storage - Chesterfield

16.9 miles away

Miles of Storage - Chesterfield

4647 East Co Road 67, Chesterfield, IN, 46017

5' x 17'

3 left
$65.00

$50.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 2148 - Muncie - Centennial Ave

19.4 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 2148 - Muncie - Centennial Ave

4440 East Centennial Avenue, Muncie, IN, 47303

10' x 15'

$56.00

$51.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 2149 - Muncie - Granville Ave

19.8 miles away

5.0(2)

Extra Space Storage - 2149 - Muncie - Granville Ave

2601 North Granville Avenue, Muncie, IN, 47303

10' x 10'

$22.00

$19.00

View All Units
Photo of Miles of Storage - Richmond

24.2 miles away

Miles of Storage - Richmond

401 Porterfield Avenue, Richmond, IN, 47374

10' x 10'

2 left
$75.00

$55.00

View All Units
Photo of Rush County Storage Main

22.5 miles away

Rush County Storage Main

900 West 3rd Street, Rushville, IN, 46173

10' x 15'

1 left

$95.00

View All Units
Photo of Bigger Garage Self-Storage - Muncie

20.8 miles away

Bigger Garage Self-Storage - Muncie

206 West Ontario Drive, Muncie, IN, 47303

10' x 10'

$57.00

View All Units
Photo of Winchester Self Storage

27.7 miles away

5.0(1)

Winchester Self Storage

184 North Middle school Road, Winchester, IN, 47394

10' x 10'

$60.00

View All Units
Photo of SmartStop Self Storage - Richmond - 1880 Williamsburg Pike

24.8 miles away

SmartStop Self Storage - Richmond - 1880 Williamsburg Pike

1880 Williamsburg Pike, Richmond, IN, 47374

10' x 10'

$72.00

$36.00

View All Units
Photo of White River Mini Storage

27.1 miles away

White River Mini Storage

1118 North Main Street, Winchester, IN, 47394

10' x 15'

3 left

$70.00

View All Units
Photo of SOA - L041 Salisbury (Richmond, Indiana)

23.1 miles away

SOA - L041 Salisbury (Richmond, Indiana)

2651 West Industries Road, Richmond, IN, 47374

10' x 10'

$50.00

View All Units
Photo of SOA -L008 Chestnut (Anderson, Indiana)

20 miles away

SOA -L008 Chestnut (Anderson, Indiana)

1201 East 5th Street, Anderson, IN, 46012

10' x 14'

1 left

$70.00

View All Units
Photo of SE Storage

19.2 miles away

5.0(2)

SE Storage

700 West 53rd Street, Anderson, IN, 46013

10' x 10'

1 left

$85.00

View All Units
Photo of Anderson Lock-Up

20.3 miles away

Anderson Lock-Up

1800 West 38th Street, Anderson, IN, 46013

10' x 10'

$65.00

View All Units

New Castle, IN Medium Self Storage Information

Self Storage Prices in New Castle, IN

Average Unit Price

Based on 26 storage units reserved in New Castle over the past 6 months.

$88.77

Up $12.73

Compared to last month

Prices ranged from $65.14 in May 2026 to $111.50 in Jun 2026.

Browse Self Storage in Nearby Indiana Cities

Browse New Castle Self Storage by Amenity

Browse New Castle Self Storage by Vehicle

TrustPilot logo

Customer reviews of SelfStorage.com

Chrisandra was very helpful and she…

Chrisandra was very helpful and she worked past closing to help me out. Thanks

I followed up with a phone call and I…

I followed up with a phone call and I was able to set everything up by phone, promptly and efficiently.

Friendly

Friendly, eager to help what we needed.

See more reviews on TrustPilot
tracking pixel
tracking pixel