31 - 60 of 69 Cheap Medium Storage Facilities in Bay Shore, NY
Sort By:
Bay Shore, NY Medium Self Storage Information
Self Storage Prices in Bay Shore, NY
Average Unit Price
Based on 82 storage units reserved in Bay Shore over the past 6 months.
$135.43
Down $8.14
Compared to last month
Prices ranged from $83.64 in May 2026 to $169.95 in Jul 2026.
Browse Self Storage in Nearby New York Cities
Browse Bay Shore Self Storage by Amenity
Browse Bay Shore Self Storage by Vehicle
Customer reviews of SelfStorage.com
It was awesome that they reached out
It was awesome that they reached out, and the process was super simple
Magic
Super useful in finding the cheapest facility near me - I could not have done it without SS. With that said, I would like more filters (entrance door size, elevator size, etc.).
Remter
Gwen was wonderful and very helpful