Cheap Drive Up Self Storage in Bay Shore, NY

Filters

1 - 30 of 37 Cheap Drive Up Storage Facilities in Bay Shore, NY

Sort By:
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 3197 - Bay Shore - Saxon Ave

1.2 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 3197 - Bay Shore - Saxon Ave

110 Saxon Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 15'

$230.00

$206.00

View All Units
Photo of Public Storage - West Babylon - 821 Sunrise Hwy

4.8 miles away

5.0(9)

Public Storage - West Babylon - 821 Sunrise Hwy

821 Sunrise Hwy, West Babylon, NY, 11704

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 20'

Deal
2 left
$471.00

$370.00

View All Units
Photo of Public Storage - Bay Shore - 122 Saxon Ave

1.2 miles away

4.5(15)

Public Storage - Bay Shore - 122 Saxon Ave

122 Saxon Ave, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 25'

1 left
$491.00

$335.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 3336 - Deer Park - Grand Blvd.

4.4 miles away

5.0(6)

Extra Space Storage - 3336 - Deer Park - Grand Blvd.

715 Grand Boulevard, Deer Park, NY, 11729

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 20'

$434.00

$404.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 4124 - North Babylon - Deer Park Ave

3.9 miles away

4.5(3)

Extra Space Storage - 4124 - North Babylon - Deer Park Ave

1251 Deer Park Avenue, North Babylon, NY, 11703

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 25'

$653.00

$623.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 7204 - Islandia - Veterans Memorial Hwy

6.3 miles away

4.0(2)

Extra Space Storage - 7204 - Islandia - Veterans Memorial Hwy

1960 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia, NY, 11749

No 5' x 5' Units Available

6' x 8'

$56.00

$50.00

10' x 10'

$101.00

$91.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 0805 - Islandia - Express Drive South

6.5 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 0805 - Islandia - Express Drive South

3016 Express Drive South, Islandia, NY, 11749

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

12' x 27'

$565.00

$535.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 0630 - Hicksville - South Broadway

13.6 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 0630 - Hicksville - South Broadway

789 South Broadway, Hicksville, NY, 11801

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 30'

$900.00

$870.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 1391 - Bohemia - Johnson Ave

8.6 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 1391 - Bohemia - Johnson Ave

510 Johnson Avenue, Bohemia, NY, 11716

5' x 5'

$58.00

$52.00

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 10'

$211.00

$189.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 4139 - Farmingville - Horseblock Rd

14 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 4139 - Farmingville - Horseblock Rd

1027 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, NY, 11738

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 25'

$346.00

$316.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 1050 - Plainview - Sunnyside Bl

12.6 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 1050 - Plainview - Sunnyside Bl

151 Sunnyside Boulevard, Plainview, NY, 11803

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

9' x 10'

$194.00

$174.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 1398 - Centereach - Middle Country Rd

11.7 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 1398 - Centereach - Middle Country Rd

2626 Middle Country Road, Centereach, NY, 11720

5' x 5'

$61.00

$54.00

5' x 10'

$96.00

$86.00

10' x 10'

$151.00

$135.00

View All Units
Photo of Public Storage - Farmingville - 951 HorseBlock Road

13.8 miles away

5.0(25)

Public Storage - Farmingville - 951 HorseBlock Road

951 HorseBlock Road, Farmingville, NY, 11738

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 20'

2 left
$334.00

$251.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 1051 - Kings Park - Indian Head Rd

10.2 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 1051 - Kings Park - Indian Head Rd

281 Indian Head Road, Kings Park, NY, 11754

No 5' x 5' Units Available

5' x 10'

Deal
$83.00

$74.00

8' x 10'

$145.00

$130.00

View All Units
Photo of StorQuest - Ronkonkoma / Lakeland

8.1 miles away

5.0(10)

StorQuest - Ronkonkoma / Lakeland

2021 Lakeland Avenue, Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 15'

1 left

$219.00

View All Units
Photo of Public Storage - Lake Ronkonkoma - 363 Portion Road

10.5 miles away

4.5(14)

Public Storage - Lake Ronkonkoma - 363 Portion Road

363 Portion Road, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 20'

1 left
$394.00

$347.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 6992 - Oakdale - Montauk Hwy

5.6 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 6992 - Oakdale - Montauk Hwy

1625 Montauk Highway, Oakdale, NY, 11769

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 30'

$515.00

$485.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 6692 - Oakdale - Sunrise Hwy

5.8 miles away

4.5(1)

Extra Space Storage - 6692 - Oakdale - Sunrise Hwy

4038 Sunrise Highway, Oakdale, NY, 11769

No 5' x 5' Units Available

5' x 10'

$115.00

$104.00

No 10' x 10' Units Available

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 1033 - Brentwood - Express Dr So

5.5 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 1033 - Brentwood - Express Dr So

200 Express Drive South, Brentwood, NY, 11717

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 10'

$163.00

$146.00

View All Units
Photo of Public Storage - Melville - 965 Walt Whitman Road

10.2 miles away

5.0(13)

Public Storage - Melville - 965 Walt Whitman Road

965 Walt Whitman Road, Melville, NY, 11747

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 25'

1 left
$552.00

$377.00

View All Units
Photo of Public Storage - Nesconset - 770 Nesconset Hwy

9.9 miles away

4.5(12)

Public Storage - Nesconset - 770 Nesconset Hwy

770 Nesconset Hwy, Nesconset, NY, 11767

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 15'

Deal
1 left
$319.00

$218.00

View All Units
Photo of Public Storage - Bayport - 709 Church St

10.8 miles away

Public Storage - Bayport - 709 Church St

709 Church St, Bayport, NY, 11705

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 20'

Deal
1 left

$313.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 0722 - East Northport - Jericho Turnpike

8.9 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 0722 - East Northport - Jericho Turnpike

4057 Jericho Turnpike, East Northport, NY, 11731

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 25'

$626.00

$596.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 7432 - Deer Park - Acorn St

5.7 miles away

4.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 7432 - Deer Park - Acorn St

541 Acorn Street, Deer Park, NY, 11729

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 20'

$373.00

$343.00

View All Units
Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage NY Saint James Middle Country Rd

10.1 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage NY Saint James Middle Country Rd

514 Middle Country Road, Saint James, NY, 11780

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 20'

Deal
$455.00

$273.00

View All Units
Photo of Public Storage - Farmingdale - 47 Broadhollow Road

9.6 miles away

5.0(16)

Public Storage - Farmingdale - 47 Broadhollow Road

47 Broadhollow Road, Farmingdale, NY, 11735

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 15'

Deal
1 left
$428.00

$292.00

View All Units
Photo of Public Storage - Patchogue - 601 W Sunrise Highway

11.3 miles away

5.0(25)

Public Storage - Patchogue - 601 W Sunrise Highway

601 W Sunrise Highway, Patchogue, NY, 11772

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 15'

Deal
3 left
$296.00

$202.00

View All Units
Photo of StorQuest - Deer Park / Grand

3.8 miles away

4.5(5)

StorQuest - Deer Park / Grand

960 Grand Boulevard, Deer Park, NY, 11729

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 23'

1 left

$279.00

View All Units
Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage NY Farmingdale Bi County Blvd

9.5 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage NY Farmingdale Bi County Blvd

505 Bi County Boulevard, Farmingdale, NY, 11735

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 25'

Deal
$763.00

$457.80

View All Units
Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage - North Babylon

3.9 miles away

4.5(5)

CubeSmart Self Storage - North Babylon

240 Bay Shore Road, North Babylon, NY, 11703

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

20' x 20'

Deal
$1,057.00

$634.20

View All Units

Bay Shore, NY Drive-Up Self Storage Information

Self Storage Prices in Bay Shore, NY

Average Unit Price

Based on 82 storage units reserved in Bay Shore over the past 6 months.

$135.43

Down $8.14

Compared to last month

Prices ranged from $83.64 in May 2026 to $169.95 in Jul 2026.

Browse Self Storage in Nearby New York Cities

Browse Bay Shore Self Storage by Amenity

Browse Bay Shore Self Storage by Vehicle

TrustPilot logo

Customer reviews of SelfStorage.com

5 star

5 star, very helpful staff member. Selecting and booking our car storage space was easy. Thank you!

Fast easy process

Fast easy process. Friendly staff.

Very easy to set up

Very easy to set up

See more reviews on TrustPilot
tracking pixel
tracking pixel