Cheap Medium Self Storage Units in Bay Shore, NY

Filters

1 - 30 of 69 Cheap Medium Storage Facilities in Bay Shore, NY

Sort By:
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 4167 - Islip - Moffitt Blvd

1.8 miles away

5.0(2)

Extra Space Storage - 4167 - Islip - Moffitt Blvd

260 Moffitt Boulevard, Islip, NY, 11751

10' x 10'

$194.00

$173.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 3197 - Bay Shore - Saxon Ave

1.2 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 3197 - Bay Shore - Saxon Ave

110 Saxon Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

10' x 10'

$199.00

$179.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 4281 - Bay Shore - Howells Rd

1.6 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 4281 - Bay Shore - Howells Rd

225 Howells Road, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

10' x 10'

$147.00

$132.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 7995 - Huntington Station - 403 Oakwood Rd

12.5 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 7995 - Huntington Station - 403 Oakwood Rd

403 Oakwood Road, Huntington Station, NY, 11746

10' x 10'

$344.00

$314.00

View All Units
Photo of SecureSpace Self Storage Deer Park

4.6 miles away

SecureSpace Self Storage Deer Park

999 Long Island Avenue, Deer Park, NY, 11729

10' x 10'

Deal
3 left

$108.00

View All Units
Photo of Public Storage - West Babylon - 821 Sunrise Hwy

4.8 miles away

5.0(9)

Public Storage - West Babylon - 821 Sunrise Hwy

821 Sunrise Hwy, West Babylon, NY, 11704

10' x 10'

Deal
$225.00

$201.00

View All Units
Photo of Public Storage - Bay Shore - 122 Saxon Ave

1.2 miles away

4.5(15)

Public Storage - Bay Shore - 122 Saxon Ave

122 Saxon Ave, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

10' x 10'

Deal
1 left
$190.00

$130.00

View All Units
Photo of Prime Storage - Bohemia Lakeland Ave.

8 miles away

Prime Storage - Bohemia Lakeland Ave.

1590 Lakeland Avenue, Bohemia, NY, 11716

10' x 10'

Deal
$219.00

$214.00

View All Units
Photo of Prime Storage - Bayshore - Pine Aire Drive

3.7 miles away

4.5(1)

Prime Storage - Bayshore - Pine Aire Drive

99 Pine Aire Drive, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

10' x 10'

2 left
$306.00

$197.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 3336 - Deer Park - Grand Blvd.

4.4 miles away

5.0(6)

Extra Space Storage - 3336 - Deer Park - Grand Blvd.

715 Grand Boulevard, Deer Park, NY, 11729

10' x 10'

$126.00

$113.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 4124 - North Babylon - Deer Park Ave

3.9 miles away

4.5(3)

Extra Space Storage - 4124 - North Babylon - Deer Park Ave

1251 Deer Park Avenue, North Babylon, NY, 11703

10' x 10'

Deal
$130.00

$117.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 7204 - Islandia - Veterans Memorial Hwy

6.3 miles away

4.0(2)

Extra Space Storage - 7204 - Islandia - Veterans Memorial Hwy

1960 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia, NY, 11749

10' x 10'

$101.00

$91.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 3330 - Lindenhurst - East Hoffman Avenue

6.9 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 3330 - Lindenhurst - East Hoffman Avenue

101 East Hoffman Avenue, Lindenhurst, NY, 11757

10' x 10'

$173.00

$155.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 3342 - Farmingdale - Executive Blvd

9.5 miles away

4.5(2)

Extra Space Storage - 3342 - Farmingdale - Executive Blvd

1 Executive Boulevard, Farmingdale, NY, 11735

10' x 15'

$242.00

$217.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 3337 - Amityville - Sterling Place

9.6 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 3337 - Amityville - Sterling Place

24 Sterling Place, Amityville, NY, 11701

10' x 10'

$146.00

$131.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 0674 - Hauppauge - Old Willets Path

5.9 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 0674 - Hauppauge - Old Willets Path

730 Old Willets Path, Hauppauge, NY, 11788

10' x 10'

$146.00

$131.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 7203 - Huntington Station - Oakwood Rd

12.5 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 7203 - Huntington Station - Oakwood Rd

380 Oakwood Road, Huntington Station, NY, 11746

6' x 16'

$172.00

$154.00

View All Units
Photo of Public Storage - Hauppauge - 745 Old Willets Path

5.8 miles away

Public Storage - Hauppauge - 745 Old Willets Path

745 Old Willets Path, Hauppauge, NY, 11788

10' x 10'

Deal
$211.00

$144.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 0805 - Islandia - Express Drive South

6.5 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 0805 - Islandia - Express Drive South

3016 Express Drive South, Islandia, NY, 11749

10' x 10'

$114.00

$102.00

View All Units
Photo of Prime Storage - Central Islip

4.6 miles away

5.0(4)

Prime Storage - Central Islip

625 Eastview Drive, Central Islip, NY, 11722

10' x 10'

Deal
$221.00

$149.00

View All Units
Photo of Public Storage - Farmingdale - 305 Del Dr

9.5 miles away

4.5(28)

Public Storage - Farmingdale - 305 Del Dr

305 Del Dr, Farmingdale, NY, 11735

10' x 10'

Deal
$216.00

$147.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 6283 - Massapequa - Old Sunrise Hwy

10.1 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 6283 - Massapequa - Old Sunrise Hwy

5660 Old Sunrise Highway, Massapequa, NY, 11758

10' x 10'

$180.00

$163.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 0630 - Hicksville - South Broadway

13.6 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 0630 - Hicksville - South Broadway

789 South Broadway, Hicksville, NY, 11801

10' x 10'

$151.00

$135.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 1391 - Bohemia - Johnson Ave

8.6 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 1391 - Bohemia - Johnson Ave

510 Johnson Avenue, Bohemia, NY, 11716

10' x 10'

$198.00

$178.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 7569 - Bay Shore - 5th Ave

3.1 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 7569 - Bay Shore - 5th Ave

1775 5th Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

10' x 10'

$129.00

$116.00

View All Units
Photo of Prime Storage - Bohemia - Lincoln Avenue

8.9 miles away

4.5(10)

Prime Storage - Bohemia - Lincoln Avenue

868 Lincoln Avenue, Bohemia, NY, 11716

10' x 10'

Deal
$187.00

$108.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 3894 - Patchogue - Sunrise Hwy

11.6 miles away

5.0(2)

Extra Space Storage - 3894 - Patchogue - Sunrise Hwy

500 Sunrise Highway, Patchogue, NY, 11772

10' x 10'

$127.00

$114.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 4139 - Farmingville - Horseblock Rd

14 miles away

5.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 4139 - Farmingville - Horseblock Rd

1027 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, NY, 11738

10' x 10'

$153.00

$139.00

View All Units
Photo of Extra Space Storage - 1050 - Plainview - Sunnyside Bl

12.6 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 1050 - Plainview - Sunnyside Bl

151 Sunnyside Boulevard, Plainview, NY, 11803

10' x 10'

$122.00

$110.00

View All Units
Photo of Prime Storage - Farmingdale

9.1 miles away

4.5(10)

Prime Storage - Farmingdale

2091 New Highway, Farmingdale, NY, 11735

10' x 10'

Deal
$169.00

$140.00

View All Units

Bay Shore, NY Medium Self Storage Information

Self Storage Prices in Bay Shore, NY

Average Unit Price

Based on 82 storage units reserved in Bay Shore over the past 6 months.

$135.43

Down $8.14

Compared to last month

Prices ranged from $83.64 in May 2026 to $169.95 in Jul 2026.

Browse Self Storage in Nearby New York Cities

Browse Bay Shore Self Storage by Amenity

Browse Bay Shore Self Storage by Vehicle

TrustPilot logo

Customer reviews of SelfStorage.com

It was awesome that they reached out

It was awesome that they reached out, and the process was super simple

Magic

Super useful in finding the cheapest facility near me - I could not have done it without SS. With that said, I would like more filters (entrance door size, elevator size, etc.).

Remter

Gwen was wonderful and very helpful

See more reviews on TrustPilot
tracking pixel
tracking pixel